Looking for the best property management companies in Columbus? Hiring a property management company can make all the difference as a property owner. From tenant screening and placement to eviction protection and maintenance, you want to be sure you have a reliable management team on your side. We’ll be the first to tell you how important it is to hire the right company, but we also know just how tough it can be to find them. That’s why we’ve done the research and put together this list of the best property managers in Columbus, Ohio. We’ll look at pricing (when available), specialties, Google ratings, and more to help simplify your hunt for the best of the best. But, before we dive in, it’s important to note that there are cases where a property manager (including us) might not be the best option for you. Watch this video to find out a few ways you can know for sure.
Evernest
Evernest was established in 2008 at the beginning of the housing crisis. Our founder, Matthew Whitaker, was left with 30 investment properties that he intended to sell but was unable to do so when the residential housing market crashed. So he searched for a property manager who shared his management philosophies and ideals. Later on in the year, Matthew launched Evernest and we officially opened for business. In the last 15 years, Evernest has grown from a team of 3 to a nationwide company with over 400 team members. Evernest is based in Birmingham and operates in 33 real estate markets across the US. With Evernest you’ll receive in-house maintenance, no fees for cancellation, and a waived lease fee if a resident leaves within the first year. Evernest guarantees a qualified renter for your unit within 21 days, or your first two months of management are free. A 24-hour hotline is available to residents as well. CEO/Founder: Matthew Whitaker BBB rating: A+ Google rating: 4.5/5 (9,669 reviews) Years in business: 15 Number of people: 400+ Rentals managed: 15,000+ Number of markets: 33 Specialties: Single-family residential, condos, small multifamily (up to 49 units), rental property investing Property management fee: 8%-10% Leasing fee: 50% of one month's rent ($500 minimum) Renewal leasing fee: $250 Other services: brokerage, in-house maintenance, in-house underwriting, leasing Learn more here
PMI Scioto Metro
PMI is a national property management company serving the Columbus area with specialized, local property managers at its Scioto Metro branch. Due to PMI’s national reach and extensive industry knowledge, they offer a diverse range of management services to real estate owners. They pride themselves in customizing their management approach to each client’s individual needs with a focus on giving back to the community. CEO/Founder: Adrian Birchler BBB rating: A+ Google rating: 5.0 (25 reviews) Years in business: PMI parent company 20+ years, PMI Scioto Metro established in 2022 Number of people: 1 Number of markets: 15 Specialties: Single-family and master-planned homes, townhomes, cooperatives, condominiums and high rises, commercial and office parks, mixed-use and PUD Property management fee: NA (must request bid for pricing) Leasing fee: NA (must request bid for pricing) Renewal leasing fee: NA (must request bid for pricing) Other services: Self-managed management services Learn more here
MVP Property Management
MVP Property Management is a women-run and -owned full-service property management company serving Columbus, Franklin County, and surrounding areas. MVP is women-owned and run and together, they have over 50 years of experience in real estate, investing, and property management. They have personally managed portfolios to generate passive income and are adept at achieving these same results for their clients. CEO/Founder: Yvonne Hughes BBB rating: N/A Google rating: 5.0 (12 reviews) Years in business: 5+ Number of people: 2 Number of markets: 20+ Specialties: single-family homes, multifamily homes Property management fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Leasing fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Renewal leasing fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Other services: real estate sales, negotiation, investing, renovation Learn more here
Access More Property Management
Access More Property Management was founded in 2017. The family-owned-and-operated company specializes in helping investors revitalize distressed properties and promoting underserved areas and Section 8 housing. They specialize in property management for single-family homes, condominiums, and apartment homes. They offer standard maintenance services all the way up to complete remodels to ensure their clients’ properties are high-quality living experiences for their tenants. CEO/Founder: Antonio D'Alberto BBB rating: A+ Google rating: 4.9 (35 reviews) Years in business: 6 Number of people: N/A Number of markets: 20+ Specialties: single-family homes, condominiums, and apartment homes Property management fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Leasing fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Renewal leasing fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Other services: N/A Learn more here
Northpoint Asset Management
Northpoint Asset Management are experts in leasing and property management services with over 30 years of industry experience. They pride themselves on their marketing tactics to ensure effective and efficient tenant placement as well as consistent property inspections to ensure care is taken with each of their client’s properties. President: Adam Haleck BBB rating: A+ Google rating: 4.7 (49 reviews) Years in business: 17 Number of people: 100+ Number of markets: 31+ Specialties: single-family homes, condominiums, multifamily apartments, commercial office buildings Property management fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Leasing fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Renewal leasing fee: NA (must contact for pricing) Other services: asset management, real estate investment, private equity Learn more here
Manage with Evernest in Columbus
There are several things to take into account while looking for the best property management companies in Columbus. In the end, it comes down to your individual circumstances and objectives. The ideal property manager will match your personal preferences as an owner, be within your budget, and cover you where you need them most. That’s why having options is important when making the right decisions for your real estate requirements. If you’re considering Evernest as your property management company, we’d love to answer your questions! For more information about property management services and fees in Columbus, visit our pricing page here.
Ready to Learn More?
Join the Evernest Educational Community! We know firsthand how hard it is to find quality resources. Oftentimes, all the information you need is scattered across the web and you’re left scrambling to find your footing. That’s why we set out to create a space where investors can get everything they need to be successful in real estate, all on one platform. We’ve put together investor tools (calculators, tutorials, and more), a listing channel where you can both buy and sell properties, a space to network with other investors and pros in the community and more. It’s completely free to join, no strings attached. Plus, there’s something for everyone, whether you’re brand new or a seasoned pro. So what are you waiting for? Join our community today and start connecting with like-minded real estate investors who share your passions and goals. We can’t wait to welcome you into the fold!
Methodology for Selecting the Best Property Management Companies in Columbus, Ohio
This list of the best property management companies in Tampa, Florida, was developed with Tampa’s distinctive real estate market in mind. From waterfront homes to bustling urban areas and quiet suburban neighborhoods, the city offers a wide range of property types and tenant needs. Our goal is to help property owners find companies equipped to handle Tampa’s increasing rental demands and the unique challenges of its dynamic housing market.
Core Evaluation Criteria and Considerations
We developed this list through a comprehensive evaluation process, taking into account several critical factors to ensure property owners in Columbus can rely on the companies featured:
Reputation and Community Trust: Companies with a strong history of success in Columbus, backed by positive customer feedback and reliable ratings on platforms like Google and BBB, were prioritized. Special consideration was given to those with a history of long-standing relationships in the community.
Coverage of Columbus Neighborhoods: Columbus is home to a variety of distinct neighborhoods, from the trendy Short North Arts District to the historic charm of German Village and the family-friendly suburbs of Dublin. We focused on companies with demonstrated expertise in managing properties across these varied areas, ensuring they can cater to different market demands.
Diverse Service Offerings: Top companies offer more than just basic property management services. We evaluated tenant placement, maintenance coordination, and financial reporting capabilities, while also giving extra credit to companies providing innovative offerings like preventive maintenance plans, tenant insurance solutions, or tailored leasing strategies.
Transparent and Competitive Fees: Pricing is a major consideration for property owners, so we prioritized companies with clear fee structures and no hidden charges. Affordability was balanced with the quality of services provided to ensure value for money.
Professional Qualifications: Affiliations with industry organizations like the National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM®) or the National Association of Realtors (NAR) were used as markers of professional credibility and ethical practices.
Commitment to Communication: We examined how companies interact with both property owners and tenants. Firms with streamlined communication channels, dedicated support teams, and modern resident platforms were rated highly for their ability to provide responsive service.
Technology-Driven Solutions: Companies utilizing cutting-edge technology to simplify property management tasks—such as online portals for rent payments, tenant screening, and maintenance requests—were favored for their efficiency and convenience.
Columbus Market Expertise: A deep understanding of Columbus’s real estate landscape, including local regulations, seasonal market trends, and tenant preferences, was a key differentiator. Companies with the ability to adapt to the unique challenges of Columbus’s rental market received higher rankings.
Final Selection Process
The selection process involved a detailed analysis that included:
Reviewing customer reviews and ratings to gauge service quality and reliability.
Comparing service offerings to identify companies with the most comprehensive solutions for property owners.
Evaluating fee structures to ensure clarity and competitiveness.
Assessing technology adoption for improved management efficiency.
The final list highlights companies that excel in professionalism, service range, and local market knowledge, offering property owners in Columbus a trusted resource for their property management needs. By focusing on these critical elements, we ensure this guide serves as a valuable tool for navigating the Columbus rental market effectively.
